BayNewser - All The Media News By The Bay

Tweeters Rip CNN for Its Coverage (or Lack Thereof) of Iran Post-Election Demonstrations

CnnFailTweet.gifThe hashtag #CNNFail rockets to the top of Twitter's most tweeted topics over the weekend. Here's why.

---------------

Remember almost 20 years ago, on that first night of the first Gulf War, when everyone gathered around TV sets to listen to CNN's John Holliman and Peter Arnett describe Iraqi anti-aircraft guns desperately trying to shoot down U.S. bombers? CNN's reporting was revolutionary at the time. Holliman and Arnett (and anchor Bernie Shaw) were holed up in a hotel (taking cover under beds at times), but thanks to modern technology, they were able to bring everyone in the U.S. (and around the world) over to Baghdad and experience exactly what it was like to be in a city under siege. (Watch/listen to it here. (Thank you, YouTube))

Well, apparently a slew of viewers turned to CNN, CNN.com, and CNNbrk (CNN's Twitter feed) on Saturday for similarly groundbreaking coverage of the post-election demonstrations in Iran—which al Jazeera called "the biggest unrest since the 1979 revolution"—and did not find what they were looking for.

"Hours after Iranian police began clashing with tens of thousands of people in the street, the top story on CNN.com remains peoples' [sic] confusion about the switch from analog TV signals," Marshall Kirkpatrick wrote on Web technology news site ReadWriteWeb in a post titled "Dear CNN, Please Check Twitter for News About Iran."

On cable, CNN carried reports throughout the day. But it wasn't the nonstop, rolling coverage some viewers apparently were expecting.

So the viewers got mad. Over the weekend, the hashtag #CNNFail rocketed to the top of the list of Twitter's most tweeted topics.

@dogstop: #CNNfail one of the biggest news stories of the year and what do we get Palin vs. David Letterman the media talking about the media

@michaelcanfield: @ralavi Can we stop tragedy before it is too late? Ask for live coverage #CNNFail #IranElection RT Please Before It's Too Late

@AndeeD: @cnnbrk Please break into your stupid reruns of old news and cover LIVE what's happening in IRAN. You are making yourself irrelevant

BayNewser wasn't watching television this weekend, so we can't tell you what CNN or CNN.com was or what not reporting. But here are some thoughts about what may have gone wrong—and some lessons news organizations might want to take from this experience.

The lessons—after the jump.


  • CNN failed viewers' expectations. People have come to expect CNN to be the go-to destination for live, breaking news around the world. When CNN failed to deliver, people got mad.

  • Twitter made people realize what they were missing. Not only were people not getting from CNN what they wanted, they were able to turn to Twitter itself—through hashtags like #IranElection—and see all kinds of stuff going on, that wasn't being reported on CNN. The gulf between what was available elsewhere and what CNN was reporting probably made them madder.

  • Twitter gave viewers the ability to make their displeasure known. It's possible viewers were similarly outraged in the past by other instances of CNN coverage. But in the past, they didn't have an effective mechanism for making their collective displeasure known. Now they do. News organizations beware.

  • People's expectations of what news organizations can deliver may be out of whack. "Perhaps it is just that what was once rapid CNN coverage of events has been made to seem slow when we have thousands of amateur reporters Twittering from their cell phones," wrote Michael W. Jones on the blog Tech.Blorge. That might be the case, but that only means that...

  • News organizations may need to re-think how they do breaking news. That's exactly what CNN did 20 years ago—rethink how to do the news, given new technologies. Before CNN started doing live reports, TV news mostly presented finished packages. But on that fateful night in January 1991, all CNN had was two guys on a telephone line reporting what they were seeing outside their hotel window, with nothing but a static map of Iraq for visuals. It wasn't polished. And it certainly wasn't complete. But it was incredibly powerful. News organizations like CNN might now have to re-imagine how to run with a breaking news story using only tweets and cell phone pictures and citizen video.

  • CNN's Twitter feed—CNNbrk—totally failed. It's understandable that TV can't always be as nimble as real-time microblogging. But Twitter can definitely be as nimble as... Twitter. For the nearly 2 million people who signed up to stay on top of the latest breaking news via CNN's Twitter feed, surely Atlanta could have done better than the following (screenshot taken at about 4:30 p.m. ET on Sunday):

    CNNbrk-Iran.gif

    Just four tweets in 36 hours? CNN should have had a producer on point, filtering, culling, and re-tweeting the most powerful tweets coming out of Iran and elsewhere—or, if they wanted to keep CNNbrk fairly high level, at a minimum they should have redirected followers to other CNN Twitter feeds with more detailed reports.

  • new on mediabistro.com

    How to Write an Arts and Culture Review

    Learn everything you need to know to write a smart, publishable review of music, film, books, theater or any other arts and culture topic.
    Watch the video

    Email This Post

    Fill out the following information and click on the Send button in order to send this post, Tweeters Rip CNN for Its Coverage (or Lack Thereof) of Iran Post-Election Demonstrations, to a friend.
    Friend's name
    Friend's email address
    Your name
    Your email address
    Note to your friend (optional, max 200 Characters)

    Read more on BayNewser >

    All The Media News By The Bay
    BayNewser in Your Inbox
    Mobile Version
    RSS Feed
    Our Blog Network

    BayNewser

    WebNewser

    PRNewser

    TVNewser

    MobileContentToday

    FishbowlNY

    FishbowlDC

    FishbowlLA

    MediaJobsDaily

    AgencySpy

    GalleyCat

    UnBeige

    BayNewser Editors

    E.B. Boyd

    Jason Turbow

    Email BayNewser

    Follow BayNewser

    Anonymous Tips
    Archives

    November 2009

    October 2009

    September 2009

    August 2009

    more...


    Topics

    About

    About Us - Modules

    apple

    Archival

    Ask.com

    Awards - Bay Area

    Bay Area Blogs

    Bay Area Books

    Bay Area Film

    Bay Area J-Schools

    Bay Area Jobs

    Bay Area Journos

    Bay Area Magazines

    Bay Area Media

    Bay Area New Media

    Bay Area News Group

    Bay Area News Project

    Bay Area Newspapers

    Bay Area People

    Bay Area Radio

    Bay Area TV

    BayNewser

    Bobbles and Toys

    Business Models

    CBS 5

    Center for Investigative Reporting

    Change

    CircLabs

    Citizen Journalism

    CNET

    Comings and Goings

    Conferences & Panels

    Craigslist

    Current TV

    Digg

    Digital TV

    Dwell

    e-books

    Events - Bay Area

    Experiments

    Facebook

    FCC

    First Ammendment

    FTC

    Fun & Games

    Future of Journalism

    Google Book Settlement

    Google Stuff

    Hearst Corp.

    How Things Are Changing

    Hyper-Local

    Ideas

    Innovation

    Internet TV

    Jelli

    Journalism & Law

    KCBS

    KGO Radio

    KNBR

    KPFA

    KQED

    KRON

    KTVU

    Language

    Literature

    Marin Independent Journal

    Marketing

    McSweeney's

    Media Workers Guild

    MediaBistro

    mediabistro.com

    MediaNews Group

    Microsoft

    Mobile Media

    NBC Bay Area

    Netflix

    New American Media

    New Tools

    New York Times

    Newspapers

    Oakland Tribune

    Old Media

    Old Media-New Media Relations

    Online Advertising

    Online Journalism

    Openings and Closings

    Our Digital Lives

    Palo Alto Daily News

    Pandora

    People & Places

    People to Watch

    Pixar

    Podcasting

    Politics & New Media

    Power List

    PR

    Practice of Journalism

    radio

    Radio - Internet

    Revision3

    Right and Wrong

    Roundup

    Roundup of mediabistro.com Blogs

    Salon.com

    San Francisco Chronicle

    San Francisco Examiner

    San Jose Mercury News

    Santa Rosa Press Democrat

    Scribd

    Search

    SF Weekly

    SFGate

    Silly Stuff

    Soc Media

    Spot.us

    TechCrunch

    Technology

    TV News - Bay Area

    TV Shows

    Twitter

    Valleywag

    Video - Online

    Video Games

    ViewPass

    Warren Hellman

    Ways and Means

    Wikipedia

    Wired

    Yahoo

    YouTube

    Links

    Curbed SF

    Eater SF

    The Grotto

    The Public Press

    San Francisco Chronicle

    San Francisco Peninusla Press Club

    SF Appeal

    SFist

    Spot.us

    Wordyard
    -----------

    Boom Town

    Inside Cable News

    Romenesko

    SocialMedia.biz

    TechCrunch

    Valleywag

    Job Listings

    Featured Listings

    Client Services Manager
    SmartBrief, Inc.
    Washington, DC

    Executive Director
    New England Newspaper and Press Association
    Dedham, MA

    Shalom Sesame Project Freelance Producer
    Sesame Workshop
    New York, NY


    mediabistro.com l Member Benefits l Jobs l Freelance Marketplace l Courses l Events l Forums l Content
    mediabistro Blogs: Media News l TVNewser l GalleyCat l UnBeige l FishbowlNY l FishbowlLA l FishbowlDC l PRNewser l AgencySpy
    MobileContentToday l WebNewser l BayNewser l MediaJobsDaily l mbToolbox
    Site Map l Advertising/Sponsorships l Partners l About Us l Contact Us/Help

    internet.commediabistro.comJusttechjobs.comGraphics.com

    Search:

    WebMediaBrands Corporate Info

    Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, Permissions, Privacy Policy.
    Advertise | Newsletters | Shopping | E-mail Offers