Topic: McCain and Activist Judges

1–2 out of 2 messages
Author Message
keltoi2 Posted – 5/6/2008 6:24:19 PM | show profile
John McCain said today that Clinton and Obama would appoint "activist" judges, and claims that he would not, saying courts must apply, not make the law.

But it was the Republican judges that McCain admires on the Supreme Court who appointed Bush President in 2000, in violation of the Constitution.

Doesn't get more "activist" than that.
keltoi2 Posted – 5/6/2008 7:53:36 PM | show profile
Basically because they intervened in a situation in a way that they really shouldn't have, and they knew it, because they even said that their ruling essentially only applied to this particular case, which violates the whole "Supreme Court decisions apply to all such cases, and not one" precedent.

But this link explains it far better than I ever can.

http://www.mediasense.com/itsnotover/SupremeCourt-QA2.htm
1–2 out of 2 messages