FishbowlNY
 
Receive mediabistro.com's Daily FishbowlNY Feed via email


Daily Media Newsfeed Click here to receive mediabistro.com's Daily Media Newsfeed via email.

Thursday Sep 22, 2005

A note on sources; or, the story behind the Story

When we first saw Louise Story's front-page story in the NYT, "Many Women at Elite Colleges Set Career Path to Motherhood," we were skeptical (read all about it here). So we asked Fishtern Maureen Miller, a senior at Yale, what the reaction on campus was (incidentally, we had Maureen in mind when we wondered where the "media junkies at the school paper" were in the article).

Maureen, of course, was already on it, and pointed us to Louise Story's questionnaire. She also summed up the reaction at Yale thusly: "People are furious. Girls and guys."

Furious? That's a strong reaction. Could it be possible that this MEL-topping (still!) front-page New York Times article had misrepresented the state of affairs on campus? Selectively quoted from its sources? Left out a few salient points, like, say, the entirely other side of the story?

It could indeed. Maureen contacted one of the main sources in the article to ask about her reaction, catching her after a long day of explaining herself on campus. She said she was "very disappointed in the way my quotes/views were framed and portrayed in the article" and though she would prefer not to be named specifically, she was happy to go on the record with a few clarifications:

It saddens me that I am portrayed as an insensitive and unambitious person in the article, and really did not know that Louise was only going to quote those of us who wanted to stay at home if/when we had kids. She in fact did interview my other suitemates who answered the survey as either not wanting to have children at all, or would continue working as a mother. I am somewhat shocked that she did not include ANY of their ideas or views in the article.
We've quoted selectively here; the student did say more, and we've included her comments in full after the jump.


From a source for "Many Women at Elite Colleges Set Career Path to Motherhood," Sept. 20, 2005 in the NYT:

Hi Maureen,

I appreciate your email to ask about the questions of the survey, but I don't have them saved anywhere, and I really don't remember the
questions. In fact, I don't remember saying the quotes that were
attributed to me in the article. The survey and interviews were
conducted more than 4, 5, or even 6 months ago (the time frame is vague because Louise Story interviewed me multiple times, and even followed me around classes one day to "get an idea of who I was"), and of the many things that I do remember saying to her, she did not include in the article. The things I told her about fighting against stereotypes that people had of me as an immigrant, and how I overcame obstacles to get where I am today never appeared in the article, and what did in fact appear is a quote about "status quo" that I do not mean in that context. I appreciate all the fighting and work that other women and people have led before us to get us to the situation of women's rights today, and I believe that if I am ever dissatisfied with the situation I am in, I will fight against it. It saddens me that I am portrayed as an insensitive and unambitious person in the article, and really did not know that Louise was only going to quote those of us who wanted to stay at home if/when we had kids. She in fact did interview my other suitemates who answered the survey as either not wanting to have children at all, or would continue working as a mother. I am somewhat shocked that she did not include ANY of their ideas or views in the article.

I don't deny that I want to stop working if/when I became a mother, but I definitely don't believe that this is the right choice for every female out there! I believe that my education here at Yale is precious and I would still like to pursue my career goals, and I believe that I have every right to experience working in the fields I want to as any man would. Because of my own life experiences, I simply hold the personal attitude that I would be willing to stop my career for children if/when I have them. I hoped that my views would show how women have the equal right to decide what they want to do with their life no matter what others believed.

I'm sorry if my email seems very incoherent and I don't really articulate my thoughts well, but it's been a long day, and many people have asked me about the article amidst all the everyday responsibilities I have to deal with. I sincerely hope that this helps clarify my views, and am very disappointed in the way my quotes/views were framed and portrayed in the article.



new on mediabistro.com

Improve Your Web Life: New Sites, New Uses, New You

Streamline your online life with a tour of sites and tools you don't know about, tips for using the ones you do, and sources for easy, free software.
Watch the video

Email This Post

Fill out the following information and click on the Send button in order to send this post, A note on sources; or, the story behind the Story, to a friend.
Friend's name
Friend's email address
Your name
Your email address
Note to your friend (optional, max 200 Characters)

Read more on FishbowlNY >

Interested in advertising on FishbowlNY?

FishbowlNY: A blog about New York media

Managing Editor:
Rebecca L. Fox

Co-Editors:
Noah Davis
Glynnis MacNicol

Email:

Contributing Editor:
Diane Clehane

  FBNY twitter feed loading...

View twitter directly

Follow FishbowlNY via Twitter

Email:
About
Syndication

Anonymous Tips


mb Blogs

TVNewser

PRNewser

GalleyCat

UnBeige

MobileContentToday

AgencySpy

FishbowlDC

FishbowlLA

FishbowlNY

Archives

July 2008

June 2008

May 2008

April 2008

more...


Recent

Will Zell Go Broad?|Gertz Allowed to Keep His Sources to Himself|Do You Have What it Takes to be the Worst?|Does He Really Want the Internet Back?

In Case You're Wondering Where All the News Went

Laugh Break: 'The Cure, for the Cure, for Cancer'

Categories

About

About Us - Modules

Acquisitions

Advertising

Alternative Weeklies

AMC 2006

AMC 2007

Awards

Beijing Olympics

Books

Bottom Feeding

Breaking News

Circulation

Daily Angle

Dissecting NPR

Ellies '08

Fashion Week

Fishbowl Initiatives

FishbowlNY Poll

International

Keith Kelly Distilled

Lunch

Magazines

Markets & Media

Media Companies

Media Events

Media Lookbook

Media Minutiae

Media People

Memopad Distilled

Movies

New Media

News

Newspapers

NYT in 90 Seconds

Obituaries

Parties

Pop Culture

Radio

Scandals

Scholarly Pursuits

Strike Watch

SXSWi '08

The Crystal Ball

The Revolving Door

The State of Journalism

Time 100

TV

Video

Links

AdAge

Beet.tv

BusinessWeek | Fine on Media

Buzz Machine/Jarvis

The Colbert Report

The Corsair

Daily Show

Editor & Publisher

Ed2010

Folio:

Gawker

Gothamist

Guardian America | Media

HuffPo | Sklar/ETP

IWantMedia

Jossip

Marketwatch | Friedman

Mediapost

Media Wire Daily

NY Daily News | Gatecrasher

NY Mag | Daily Intelligencer

NY Observer | The Media Mob

NY Post | Keith Kelly

NY Sun

NYT | Business

The Onion

Paid Content

Portfolio | Bercovici

Poynter | Romenesko

Radar

Radosh

Rex Hammock

Silicon Alley Insider

Slate | Jack Shafer

Wall Street Journal

WaPo | Media Notes

James Wolcott

WWD

Forum

New York Issues 15 topics
STUDIO SPACE LOWER EAST SIDE (1) 7/24/2008
MASSAGE! HELP ME! (1) 7/15/2008
UV gel nails in NYC? (1) 6/30/2008
Renting a room in NYC (4) 6/28/2008
more... - post new topic

Subscribe

Click here to receive the Daily Media News Feed by email.

Job Listings

Featured Listings

Online Advertising Sales Executive
Web Division of Nat'l Magazine
New York, NY

Account Executive
Hunter Public Relations
New York, NY

Inside Sales Executive, Medical Publications
Boston Hannah
New York, NY

Senior Editor / Magazines
The Journal News
White Plains, NY

Upcoming

Get Over Your Writer's Block
Led by a senior editor at Penguin.
July 26

How to Cover New York Stories
Get published in New York publications.
July 30

Personal Essay Workshop
Turn a personal experience into a paid story.
August 5

Become a partner


ADVERTISEMENT


mediabistro.com l Member Benefits l Jobs l Freelance Marketplace l Courses l Events l Forums l Content
mediabistro Blogs: Media News l TVNewser l GalleyCat l UnBeige l FishbowlNY l FishbowlLA l FishbowlDC l mbToolbox l PRNewser l AgencySpy l MobileAppsToday l MobileContentToday l MobileMarketingToday l MobileDevicesToday
Site Map l Advertising/Sponsorships l Partners l About Us l Contact Us/Help

JupiterOnlineMedia

internet.comearthweb.comDevx.commediabistro.comGraphics.com

Search:

Jupitermedia Corporation has two divisions: Jupiterimages and JupiterOnlineMedia

Jupitermedia Corporate Info


Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, & Permissions, Privacy Policy.

Web Hosting | Newsletters | Tech Jobs | Shopping | E-mail Offers