Today Mike Barnicle, filling in for Chris Matthews, and his guests, Pat Buchanan and Joan Walsh, all agreed Bill O’Reilly was not getting talking points from the Bush White House, as McClellan had at first indicated on Friday.
“I agree with Bill O’Reilly here, I don’t think he’d take talking points from anyone,” said Barnicle. “He’s not taking talking points from…he’s not taking them from Roger Ailes, he’s not taking them from anyone.”
“I think the guy wouldn’t have the ratings he does, have the audience he does, if he’s spouting the party line,” said Buchanan.
Even the guest representing the left, Walsh, agreed. While joking, “This story for liberals was too good not to be true,” she said, “Its rare that I would ever come to Bill O’Reilly’s defense. But I don’t see any evidence at this point that they were officially disseminating points one through nine and they were then being parroted on Fox News.”
> More: Click continued to see the Hardball segment…
- 'Smells Good...Smells Like College': Rachel Maddow Tours Colorado Pot Shop
- Cable News Ranker: October 2014
- October 2014 Ratings: MSNBC Has Lowest Rated Month Since 2005
- MSNBC's Al Sharpton Reveals He Hasn't Eaten Dinner In Years