Countdown: “Intellectually Incestuous”

As Countdown with Keith Olbermann approaches its 5th anniversary, Allyourtv.com’s Rick Ellis has some thoughts on MSNBC’s highest-rated program:

The problem for me is that Countdown is rapidly becoming predictable and generic; a distressing development for a show that really has its own internal vibe and attitude. I still watch the show every night, but there are times when my interest fades, and I find myself hitting the fast forward button to get through a segment.

Ellis has issues with the narrow guest list (ie Dana Milbank, pictured, during Harry Whittington-gate) and how the segments unfold:

The typical conversation consists of Olbermann saying, “Point a, point b and then point c.” Then the guest agrees with all three points, and perhaps brings in point b2 as a way of expanding the conversation. It all has a “Groundhog’s Day” quality to it that I find maddening.

Ellis’s solution:

I would like to see a wider list of guests, and the occasional comment from them that surprises me. I want the overall show to be as smart and unexpected as Olbermann’s segments, and that certainly isn’t the case right now.

It also might be fun to intermittently bring in a guest who can nicely disagree with Olbermann.

• Related: The TVNewser interview with Keith Olbermann…

Create a social media strategy, launch your campaign, and track the results in our Social Media Marketing Boot Camp starting February 16. The online event and workshop will feature speakers including The Onion‘s Baratunde Thurston (left), Facebook’s Morin Oluwole, and bitly’s Tim Devane. Register now.