AdsoftheWorld BrandsoftheWorld LostRemote AgencySpy PRNewser TVNewser TVSpy FishbowlNY FishbowlDC GalleyCat

Posts Tagged ‘Burn-Back’

Behind the Portfolio Night

portfolionight.gif

After we questioned the screening process of Portfolio Night the folks from ihaveanidea wanted to clarify a few things, and contacted us with a more detailed description of how they decide who attends. Seeing as we’re an equal opportunity blog, of course we agreed to post it (plus we were way afraid that the drummer from Burn Back would come after us if we didn’t):

When someone is unsure of their work and sends it in, it goes to the editorial staff at ihaveanidea. It gets reviewed by us, who in addition to running ihaveanidea also work in advertising or have experience in it. We then let the student know if we feel they would benefit from the event.

Most times we encourage them to come out. But there are some instances when we advise the student that there is just far too much work needed on the portfolio to attend the event–and then we explain to them where those weaknesses are and suggestions on addressing them. At the end of the day a Creative Director can only do so much in the 15 minutes they will spend with each student. We try to ensure that the students who attend are the ones who will benefit the most from those 15 minutes, whether it be in suggestions to make a good book great, or a possible job offer.

So there you have it, and although we don’t agree with a screening process at all, we’d like to point out that 15 minutes is plenty of time to dispense life-changing career advice. Really, how long does it take to say “Is there a reason you printed your ads out backwards?” (6 seconds) or “Have you considered a career in copywriting instead?” (5 seconds) or “Don’t worry about your book, advertising is really more about the ability to drink heavily throughout the day. Wild Turkey?” (10 seconds)

Mediabistro Course

Mediabistro Job Fair

Mediabistro Job FairLand your next big gig! Join us on Janaury 27  at the Altman Building in New York City for an incredible opportunity to meet with hiring managers from the top New York media compaies, network with other professionals and industry leaders, and land your next job. Register now!

“Make the Logo Bigger”=”You’re Not Good Enough For Our Portfolio Review”

portfolionight.jpg

We haven’t been able to get “Make the Logo Bigger” out of our heads, either, ever since the DJs at Speak Up added it to their playlist. The song is performed by the band Burn Back (get it?) who have since released another single, “Squeeze My Whipple” (get it?), and created a “Behind the Music” about their rise to fame. This clever ploy promotes the global advertising event Portfolio Night, which will be holding reviews in dozens of cities on May 3. It seemed pretty exciting until we saw this:

How do you know if your book is good enough to attend Portfolio Night?

Send your ads to education@ihaveanidea.org and we’ll tell you.

Maybe we’ve had one too many bourbons this morning, but isn’t the whole point of a portfolio review to have people tell you in person if your ads are good enough? We emailed them to find out and here’s the deal: Should you send them some of your ads, the staff of ihaveanidea will review it themselves, and tell you if you’d benefit from the event. They may even tell you that there’s too much work needed on your portfolio, and not to bother attending.

Huh? We turned to our friend Spencer Cross who just happens to be holding a portfolio review here in LA the same day…

Read more