#25. Nick Johnson
– Draft: 89th overall pick in 1996
– Position: First baseman
– Games played: 832
– Career stats: 95 home runs, .268 batting average, .840 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 14.5
#24. Jim Beattie
– Draft: 91st overall pick in 1975
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 203
– Career stats: 52 wins, 4.17 earned run average, 1.42 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 14.8
#23. Tyler Clippard
– Draft: 274th overall pick in 2003
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 807
– Career stats: 56 wins, 3.16 earned run average, 1.11 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 15.9
#21. Brad Ausmus (tie)
– Draft: 1152nd overall pick in 1987
– Position: Catcher
– Games played: 1,971
– Career stats: 80 home runs, .252 batting average, .669 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 16.5
#21. Eric Milton (tie)
– Draft: 20th overall pick in 1996
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 271
– Career stats: 89 wins, 4.99 earned run average, 1.34 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 16.5
#20. Ian Kennedy
– Draft: 21st overall pick in 2006
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 497
– Career stats: 104 wins, 4.16 earned run average, 1.29 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 17.0
#19. Doc Medich
– Draft: 700th overall pick in 1970
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 312
– Career stats: 124 wins, 3.78 earned run average, 1.33 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 19.6
#18. Scott McGregor
– Draft: 14th overall pick in 1972
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 356
– Career stats: 138 wins, 3.99 earned run average, 1.29 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 20.2
#17. Carl Everett
– Draft: 10th overall pick in 1990
– Position: Outfielder
– Games played: 1,405
– Career stats: 202 home runs, .271 batting average, .802 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 20.4
#15. David Robertson (tie)
– Draft: 524th overall pick in 2006
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 817
– Career stats: 65 wins, 2.9 earned run average, 1.15 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 20.8
#15. Bob Tewksbury (tie)
– Draft: 493rd overall pick in 1981
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 302
– Career stats: 110 wins, 3.92 earned run average, 1.29 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 20.8
#14. Austin Jackson
– Draft: 259th overall pick in 2005
– Position: Outfielder
– Games played: 1,115
– Career stats: 65 home runs, .273 batting average, .729 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 22.1
#13. Stan Bahnsen
– Draft: 68th overall pick in 1965
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 574
– Career stats: 146 wins, 3.6 earned run average, 1.33 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 22.7
#12. Mike Lowell
– Draft: 562nd overall pick in 1995
– Position: Second baseman
– Games played: 1,601
– Career stats: 223 home runs, .279 batting average, .805 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 24.8
#11. Greg Gagne
– Draft: 129th overall pick in 1979
– Position: Shortstop
– Games played: 1,798
– Career stats: 111 home runs, .254 batting average, .684 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 26.3
#10. Al Leiter
– Draft: 50th overall pick in 1984
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 419
– Career stats: 162 wins, 3.8 earned run average, 1.39 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 40.0
#9. Don Mattingly
– Draft: 493rd overall pick in 1979
– Position: First baseman
– Games played: 1,785
– Career stats: 222 home runs, .307 batting average, .830 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 42.4
#8. Jorge Posada
– Draft: 646th overall pick in 1990
– Position: Shortstop
– Games played: 1,829
– Career stats: 275 home runs, .273 batting average, .848 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 42.7
#7. Brett Gardner
– Draft: 109th overall pick in 2005
– Position: Outfielder
– Games played: 1,688
– Career stats: 139 home runs, .256 batting average, .740 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 44.3
#6. Aaron Judge
– Draft: 32nd overall pick in 2013
– Position: Centerfielder
– Games played: 897
– Career stats: 278 home runs, .282 batting average, .989 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 45.6
#5. Thurman Munson
– Draft: 4th overall pick in 1968
– Position: Catcher
– Games played: 1,423
– Career stats: 113 home runs, .292 batting average, .756 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 46.1
#4. Ron Guidry
– Draft: 67th overall pick in 1971
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 368
– Career stats: 170 wins, 3.29 earned run average, 1.18 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 47.8
#3. Fred McGriff
– Draft: 233rd overall pick in 1981
– Position: First baseman
– Games played: 2,460
– Career stats: 493 home runs, .284 batting average, .886 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 52.6
#2. Andy Pettitte
– Draft: 594th overall pick in 1990
– Position: Pitcher
– Games played: 531
– Career stats: 256 wins, 3.85 earned run average, 1.35 walks plus hits per inning
– Wins above replacement: 60.2
#1. Derek Jeter
– Draft: 6th overall pick in 1992
– Position: Shortstop
– Games played: 2,747
– Career stats: 260 home runs, .310 batting average, .817 on-base plus slugging
– Wins above replacement: 71.3