GalleyCat
 
Receive mediabistro.com's Daily GalleyCat Feed via email


Daily Media Newsfeed Click here to receive mediabistro.com's Daily Media Newsfeed via email.

Monday Feb 12, 2007

Why Does Maureen Dowd Hate Popular Women?

"Hey, Maureen, 2003 called," quips Whitney Gaskell, "it wants its column back." Not without reason, that's become one of the easiest comebacks to Maureen Dowd's handwringing over bestselling chick lit writers; at my other blog, Beatrice.com, Sarahbeth Purcell dates Dowd (right) all the way back to 1997. (Kyra Davis also shares sarcasm-laced gratitude for the slam against her genre.) "Her column breaks no new ground, offers no new evidence, and it's marred by some impressively lazy arguments," Jennifer Weiner writes, before tearing into one especially insipid element of Dowd's broadside: "I seriously doubt that the readers who enjoy their Jane Green, Sophie Kinsella, Emily Giffin et al will be throwing down their pink books and making a mad dash for The Red Badge of Courage on Leon Wieseltier's say-so. I can't speak for anyone else, but as for me? I read it in high school."

Whitney Gaskell's email went on to refute Dowd's dismissal of the genre as irrelevant frippery. "How many chick lit critics have actually read beyond the cover copy? They always seem to miss the fact that behind the pink covers, books in this genre are often thoughtful and richly drawn, covering topics from rape to infidelity, from infertility to finding one's path in life," Gaskell emails. "In other words, they're books that are relevant and real to the women who read them. I wonder if Ms. Dowd and Mr. Wieseltier—who pompously decries chick lit as too fluffy and thus inappropriate for these serious times—have similar objections to readers picking up the latest Carl Hiaasen or Robert Parker? Or is it only offensive to them when women writers turn their pens to commercial fiction?"


"One of the many things I admire about men is that they are unashamedly comfortable about their tastes in relaxation," concurs British novelist Lauren Henderson, who's penned several mysteries and romantic comedies as well as Jane Austen's Guide to Dating, in support of that idea. "The venom with which Dowd spits out the words 'Harlequin romances' suggests a hate of her own gender—not to mention a narrowminded attitude that assumes that a woman can't enjoy novels by Sophie Kinsella as well as those by Toni Morrison." She adds that the best writers offered to readers as chick lit are "funnier, snappier, and write considerably better" than Dowd does while trying to criticize the genre, sniffing: "Someone making snotty remarks about 'Sex and the City reruns' should try a little harder to sound less like a poor imitation of Carrie Bradshaw." (Then again, Lauren Lipton remarks, "Here's a gal whose livelihood is based on a tiresome catty-chick schtick; reading her column is like being forced to listen to some endlessly snippy, shallow sorority girl.")

Stella Duffy, Henderson's comrade in the "Tart City" movement of women crime writers, advances this theme further in her comments. "When (name any woman writer, ever) writes about family/relationships she is considered domestic. When Mike Leigh does exactly the same (only with added shouting by the women, which he equates with 'character') he is considered universal," Duffy observes. "Dowd is only reiterating the classic view that men's work is valid when women's is for women only. We know the stats: Women read women and men, men read men. That's it. That's how it is. And until we change that one, what is considered 'women's fiction' will continue to be denigrated, by both women and men, because it's an easy buck to slag it off. It is a feminist issue. But it might require the women—and men—involved (on both sides of the fence, those successful in the work and those denigrating it) to get involved in the discussion to make a difference."



new on mediabistro.com

Improve Your Web Life: New Sites, New Uses, New You

Streamline your online life with a tour of sites and tools you don't know about, tips for using the ones you do, and sources for easy, free software.
Watch the video

Email This Post

Fill out the following information and click on the Send button in order to send this post, Why Does Maureen Dowd Hate Popular Women?, to a friend.
Friend's name
Friend's email address
Your name
Your email address
Note to your friend (optional, max 200 Characters)

Read more on GalleyCat >

Interested in advertising on GalleyCat?

GalleyCat.com: the first word on the book publishing industry

galleycat-sidebar-shadow.jpg

Editors: Ron Hogan
Andy Heidel

Contributing Editor:
Emily Gould




rss-feed-icon-64x64.jpg

more feeds from mediabistro.com

Anonymous Tips

Guidelines For Use

Favorite Posts

galleycat-sidebar-shadow2.jpg

The Last Whiny Editor Email We Ever Ran


Where Will We Find Literature's Radiohead?

A Miss Is a Hit on a Different Target

Your Negative Attitude Won't Save Literacy

The More Book Critics Change, The More They Stay the Same

In Which Philosophical Enquiry Disabuses Me of An Insidious Preconception

It's Hard Out There For a Literary Novelist

jack-romanos-button.jpg
The Exit Interview with Jack Romanos

porochista-khakpour-button.jpg
Flammable Author Refuses to Be Silenced or Pigeonholed

michael-rogers-button.jpg
The Futurist in the Attic

diane-vadino-button.jpg
Don't Let the Pink Cover Faze You

Obscure Literati Cry Out for Amazon's Attention

The NYTBR and the Case of the Misplaced Corpse

ellen-litman-button.jpg
A Chat with Ellen Litman

kimberlee-auerbach.jpg
Tarot Memoirist Draws Winning Hand

Oh Noes! Peoples Stopped Reading! We Is Doomed!

vincent-lam-button.jpg
A Chat with Vincent Lam

eric-kampmann-button.jpg
Eric Kampmann Defends If I Did It Deal

America's Readers a Pack of Bloodthirsty Ghouls

rakesh-satyal-button.jpg
Going to a Town, Feelin' Like a Criminal

Lunch with Leslie & Lesley

anna-david-button.jpg
Chick Lit Is Never a Compliment

Touring the Met with Danny Danziger

Thomas Nelson's Densely Packed Brand Nucleus

Jumping on the Mattress of the Book Review's Deathbed

laura-albert-button.jpg
Laura Albert: "Not Sorry," Moving On

Our Exit Interview with Don Weise

Old Man, Look at My Blog

It's Not Just a Book Review Crisis

Blogs Under Fire in LA

Publishers, Techies Love Each Other Up

Pop Fiction Unaffected by Lit Crit Demise

Librarians Squirm at Cite of Scrotum


Why Does Maureen Dowd Hate Popular Women?

Maureen Dowd Discovers Chick Lit

Terry McMillan Still Bitter

jamesfrey.jpg
Haven't You Forgotten James Frey Yet?

Literary Showtune Parodies!


mb Blogs

TVNewser

PRNewser

FishbowlNY

FishbowlDC

FishbowlLA

UnBeige

MobileContentToday

AgencySpy

GalleyCat

Links

theBookseller.com

The Book Standard

Buzz, Balls & Hype

Danuta Kean

Eco-Libris

Publishers Marketplace

Publishing Contrarian

Publishing For Profit

Publishing Insider

Publishing News

The Publishing Spot
Publishing Trends

Publishers Weekly

PubRants

Shelf Awareness

Weekly Publishing Moves

...more...

Archives

May 2008

April 2008

March 2008

February 2008

more...


Recent

Fox News Tackles Literature: Class Act as Always

High Times for Children's Picture Book in CNN Potfecta

I Have a Sudden Craving for Popcorn

cats by Clipart.com, a service of Jupiterimages

Subscribe

Click here to receive the Daily Media News Feed by email.

Job Listings

Featured Listings

Managing Editor: Babytalk Magazine
Babytalk Magazine
New York, NY

Editor - SparkNotes
Barnes & Noble, Inc. - SparkNotes
New York, NY

Associate Editor
Minyanville Publishing & Multimedia
New York, NY

Book Editor
BowTie Press
Freehold, NJ

Become a partner


ADVERTISEMENT


mediabistro.com l Member Benefits l Jobs l Freelance Marketplace l Courses l Events l Forums l Content
mediabistro Blogs: Media News l TVNewser l GalleyCat l UnBeige l FishbowlNY l FishbowlLA l FishbowlDC l mbToolbox l PRNewser l AgencySpy l MobileContentToday
Site Map l Help l Advertising/Sponsorships l Store l About Us
mediabistro.com inc., call (212) 929-2588 or email wecare@mediabistro.com
PRIVACY POLICY Copyright © 2008 mediabistro.com inc. All rights reserved.
MEDIA BISTRO is a registered trademark of Laurel Touby.

JupiterOnlineMedia

internet.comearthweb.comDevx.commediabistro.comGraphics.com

Search:

Jupitermedia Corporation has two divisions: Jupiterimages and JupiterOnlineMedia

Jupitermedia Corporate Info


Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, & Permissions, Privacy Policy.

Web Hosting | Newsletters | Tech Jobs | Shopping | E-mail Offers