Welcome back to FishbowlNY’s weekly Cover Battle. Today we have W versus Fast Company. The above is actually one of four covers W did celebrating their 40th anniversary. We selected this one because Scarlett Johansson is dressed exactly like every girl we dated in high school. Hey, don’t judge. We were young, and our parents made us do chores when all we wanted to do was write angry poems. Girls who shopped at Hot Topic were the only ones who understood us and our pain.

Fast Company went with a cover shot featuring a bunch of very smart and very rich people. We told them we’d feature this cover if they each bought us an island, and they agreed.

So dear readers, which cover is better? You can vote, comment, or do both.