GalleyCat
 
Receive mediabistro.com's Daily GalleyCat Feed via email


Daily Media Newsfeed Click here to receive mediabistro.com's Daily Media Newsfeed via email.

Friday Dec 16, 2005

Nerds Bemoan Domination by Geeks

Science fiction author (and physicist) Gregory Benford laments the triumph of fantasy over sci-fi, which they argue creates "a core lessening of what I value in the larger genre, with a lot less real thinking going on about the future." This interpretation depends on a very specific argument about the purpose of science fiction, namely to function as "the canary in the mineshaft for the advanced nations, to tell us what to worry about up ahead." Some readers, however, may wonder if Benford isn't overreacting when he suggests that the end result of George R. R. Martin's A Feast For Crows debuting at #1 on the Times bestseller list will be the collapse of Western civilization:

"It's not crazy to think that a hundred years from now, Europe will be a complete backwater, a place that is essentially seen as a living museum, and the hot, big, where-it's-happening cities in the world will be Lahore or Delhi, Bangkok, Singapore, and just possibly maybe Perth, or even Darwin."

To rise to the challenge, Benford vows to stop writing science fiction and concentrate on nonfiction essays in collaboration with evolutionary biologist Michael Rose. Responses have already begun to emerge from other science fiction writers: "The problem here isn't that fantasy is stealing SF's audience," says Elizabeth Bear. "The problem is that SF isn't making itself accessible to a general audience." On his blog, Scott Lynch offers a brutal point-by-point critique of the Benford essay and its "monstrously uninformed balderdash."

John Scalzi adds, "I think tying in the rise of fantasy and decline of science fiction to ominous cultural trends feels nice, because there's nothing like being held in the pitiless thrall of a world-historical hairpin turn toward entropy to make one feel better about the fact that it's JK Rowling making a billion dollars from her books and not you." He also points to the accessibility issue, jocularly observing: "Math is hard, and science fiction looks rather suspiciously like math." (That post has generated a lot of commentary, well worth the consideration of anyone looking to write, represent, or publish sci-fi.) And all these reactions drive home the fact that this is not a new debate; just last year in fact, SF author Norman Spinrad wrote an especially hysterical essay which Matthew Cheney cleverly summarized, "Spinrad's own writing is not getting the attention it once did, nor is the writing of his friends."




new on mediabistro.com

The Future of Social Media with Chris Anderson

The editor of Wired explains how to create a social network that works.
Watch the video

Email This Post

Fill out the following information and click on the Send button in order to send this post, Nerds Bemoan Domination by Geeks, to a friend.
Friend's name
Friend's email address
Your name
Your email address
Note to your friend (optional, max 200 Characters)

Read more on GalleyCat >

Interested in advertising on GalleyCat?

Our Blog Network

TVNewser

PRNewser

FishbowlNY

FishbowlDC

FishbowlLA

UnBeige

MobileContentToday

MobileMarketingToday

MobileDevicesToday

MobileAppsToday

AgencySpy

GalleyCat.com: the first word on the book publishing industry




rss-feed-icon-64x64.jpg

more feeds from mediabistro.com

Editor:
Jason Boog

Senior Editor:
Ron Hogan

galleycat-sidebar-shadow.jpg

Anonymous Tips


Favorite Posts

galleycat-sidebar-shadow2.jpg

heather-thomas-sidebar.jpg
Our Chat With Heather Thomas

jack-oconnell-sidebar.jpg
The (Long-Awaited) Return of Jack O'Connell

marya-hornbacher-sidebar.jpg
Marya Hornbacher: "No Tortured Artists Here"

stean-sagmeister-sidebar.jpg
Stefan Sagmeister: "Design for Non-Designers"


Why Does Maureen Dowd Hate Popular Women?


Links

theBookseller.com

Buzz, Balls & Hype

Danuta Kean

Eco-Libris

Publishers Marketplace

Publishers Weekly

Publishing Contrarian

Publishing For Profit

Publishing Insider

Publishing News

The Publishing Spot

Publishing Trends

PubRants

Rick Frishman

Shelf Awareness

TeleRead

Weekly Publishing Moves

...more...

Archives

December 2008

November 2008

October 2008

September 2008

more...


Recent

Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Breakdown: Everybody's Hurt

E-Book Romancers Set Out to Capture "New Mass Market"

It's All Fun and Games for These YA Authors

cats by Clipart.com, a service of Jupiterimages

Subscribe

Click here to receive the Daily Media News Feed by email.

Job Listings

Featured Listings

Vice President of New Product Development
Thompson Publishing Group, Inc.
Washington, DC

Senior Producer, Student Activities
Scholastic
New York - SoHo, NY

Sales Assistant, National Accounts - Client Publishers
Random House U.S.A
New York, NY

Publisher
Scholastic
Palo Alto, CA

ADVERTISEMENT


mediabistro.com l Member Benefits l Jobs l Freelance Marketplace l Courses l Events l Forums l Content
mediabistro Blogs: Media News l TVNewser l GalleyCat l UnBeige l FishbowlNY l FishbowlLA l FishbowlDC l mbToolbox l PRNewser l AgencySpy l UGCX
MobileAppsToday l MobileContentToday l MobileMarketingToday l MobileDevicesToday
Site Map l Advertising/Sponsorships l Partners l About Us l Contact Us/Help

JupiterOnlineMedia

internet.comearthweb.comDevx.commediabistro.comGraphics.com

Search:

Jupitermedia Corporation has two divisions: Jupiterimages and JupiterOnlineMedia

Jupitermedia Corporate Info


Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, & Permissions, Privacy Policy.

Web Hosting | Newsletters | Tech Jobs | Shopping | E-mail Offers