GalleyCat
 
Receive mediabistro.com's Daily GalleyCat Feed via email


Daily Media Newsfeed Click here to receive mediabistro.com's Daily Media Newsfeed via email.

Monday Feb 12, 2007

Chick Literati React to Dowd's Criticism

"Maureen Dowd teeters ever closer to irrelevance today," Megan Crane commented on her blog after reading Dowd's tardy assault on chick lit in Saturday's NY Times. And that was one of the politer responses to the column Justine Larbalestier slammed on her blog as "a morass of ignorance and misinformation."

"It's a spoof, right? April Fools comes early?" one bestselling novelist emailed me. "I mean, it's not just stupid and late, it's really poorly written." Sonia Singh dropped me a line a few hours later with her take: "I hear that Dowd's next piece for the Times daringly poses the question, 'Is Rap Music Corrupting our Youth?' Did you know so many kids were listening to rap music these days? I didn't!"

aremen-necessary.jpgSome writers pointed to the sloppiness of Dowd's research—as when she built a good portion of her argument around the genre's banal tone by citing a "Brit chick lit" novel, Angus, Thongs, and Full-Frontal Snogging, that's actually marketed to YA audiences—and pretty blatantly at that, considering that it's narrated by a 14-year-old girl. Others suggested that given her recent track record as a published author, Dowd is in no position to criticize chick lit writers for their publisher's choice of cover illustrations. Lauren Baratz-Logsted went to her local bookstore to see if her impressions matched Dowd's. "While I didn't feel molested by pink covers as she apparently did," Baratz-Logsted reports via email, "I did see her book, Are Men Necessary?, with its chick-friendly title and retro Nancy Drew cover designed to appeal to chicks, and an author photo with a seductive come-hither look. I'm thinking whatever house Ms. Dowd is living in, she has no right to be throwing pink stones."

(Meanwhile, Karen Quinn pointed out that while chick lit may be beneath Dowd's intelligence, not every smart woman shares her elitist views—Quinn remembers sitting across the aisle a Nobel laureate scientist on an LA-to-NY flight a few years back who was happily absorbed in a pink-covered novel.)


Over at Smart Bitches, Trashy Books, the pile-on was quick to take shape, and the perceived anti-feminist shape of Dowd's opinion was one of the prime targets. "I fail to understand why books by disaffected young men about their inability to form relationships, their dissatisfaction at work, and the ways they screw up are always seen as literature, regardless of the quality of writing," observed Marta Acosta, "but books by women are always trivialized, even by other women." Fellow novelist Lauren Willig took an additional swing at the "multicultural Harlequin romances" label Dowd tagged the genre with. "There's certainly lots of awful chick lit out there, as there is with any genre... but at its best, chick lit affords a medium for smart social satire on the changing norms of courtship and marriage. How is that so different from Austen?"

And, via email, Tracy Quan noted the irony of Dowd attacking a genre which was pretty much invented in newspaper columns, during the original serialization of Bridget Jones's Diary. "The features editor who assigned the first Bridget Jones column was inspired by the chatter of working women," Quan recalls. "He liked the way young women would arrive at the office, start dishing about Gordon Brown or Tony Blair and suddenly they'd be talking about their lip gloss, too. He wanted Bridget's diary to reflect a way of thinking that doesn't segregate topics into neat compartments. Now, a lot of the chick-lit that came later hasn't been as funny or multi-layered as Bridget Jones because not everyone can be Helen Fielding. But the chaotic atmosphere on the bookshelves that Maureen has noticed, that's very much in the spirit of Bridget's creation!"



new on mediabistro.com

Improve Your Web Life: New Sites, New Uses, New You

Streamline your online life with a tour of sites and tools you don't know about, tips for using the ones you do, and sources for easy, free software.
Watch the video

Email This Post

Fill out the following information and click on the Send button in order to send this post, Chick Literati React to Dowd's Criticism, to a friend.
Friend's name
Friend's email address
Your name
Your email address
Note to your friend (optional, max 200 Characters)

Read more on GalleyCat >

Interested in advertising on GalleyCat?

GalleyCat.com: the first word on the book publishing industry

galleycat-sidebar-shadow.jpg

Editors: Ron Hogan
Andy Heidel




rss-feed-icon-64x64.jpg

more feeds from mediabistro.com

Anonymous Tips

Guidelines For Use

Favorite Posts

galleycat-sidebar-shadow2.jpg

"Why Can't Men Write Anymore?": An Alternate Answer

Michael Chabon & Jeffrey Ford Demolish Genre

deborah-baker-sidebar.jpg
Deborah Baker: Following the Beats Through India

heather-thomas-sidebar.jpg
Our Chat With Heather Thomas

jack-oconnell-sidebar.jpg
The (Long-Awaited) Return of Jack O'Connell

marya-hornbacher-sidebar.jpg
Marya Hornbacher: "No Tortured Artists Here"

sarah-hall-sidebar.jpg
Sarah Hall: "There Is No Future, And England's Dreaming"

isabel-fonseca-sidebar.jpg
Isabel Fonseca: Embracing the Candor of Fiction

stean-sagmeister-sidebar.jpg
Stefan Sagmeister: "Design for Non-Designers"

alex-witchel-sidebar.jpg
Alex Witchel: A Fern Among Roses?

Peter Walsh: "It's Never About the Stuff"

The Last Whiny Editor Email We Ever Ran


Where Will We Find Literature's Radiohead?

A Miss Is a Hit on a Different Target

Your Negative Attitude Won't Save Literacy

The More Book Critics Change, The More They Stay the Same

In Which Philosophical Enquiry Disabuses Me of An Insidious Preconception

It's Hard Out There For a Literary Novelist

jack-romanos-button.jpg
The Exit Interview with Jack Romanos

porochista-khakpour-button.jpg
Flammable Author Refuses to Be Silenced or Pigeonholed

michael-rogers-button.jpg
The Futurist in the Attic

diane-vadino-button.jpg
Don't Let the Pink Cover Faze You

Obscure Literati Cry Out for Amazon's Attention

The NYTBR and the Case of the Misplaced Corpse

ellen-litman-button.jpg
A Chat with Ellen Litman

kimberlee-auerbach.jpg
Tarot Memoirist Draws Winning Hand

Oh Noes! Peoples Stopped Reading! We Is Doomed!

vincent-lam-button.jpg
A Chat with Vincent Lam

eric-kampmann-button.jpg
Eric Kampmann Defends If I Did It Deal

America's Readers a Pack of Bloodthirsty Ghouls

rakesh-satyal-button.jpg
Going to a Town, Feelin' Like a Criminal

Lunch with Leslie & Lesley

anna-david-button.jpg
Chick Lit Is Never a Compliment

Touring the Met with Danny Danziger

Thomas Nelson's Densely Packed Brand Nucleus

Jumping on the Mattress of the Book Review's Deathbed

laura-albert-button.jpg
Laura Albert: "Not Sorry," Moving On

Our Exit Interview with Don Weise

Old Man, Look at My Blog

It's Not Just a Book Review Crisis

Blogs Under Fire in LA

Publishers, Techies Love Each Other Up

Pop Fiction Unaffected by Lit Crit Demise

Librarians Squirm at Cite of Scrotum


Why Does Maureen Dowd Hate Popular Women?

Maureen Dowd Discovers Chick Lit

Terry McMillan Still Bitter

jamesfrey.jpg
Haven't You Forgotten James Frey Yet?

Literary Showtune Parodies!


mb Blogs

TVNewser

PRNewser

FishbowlNY

FishbowlDC

FishbowlLA

UnBeige

MobileContentToday

AgencySpy

GalleyCat

galleycat-sidebar-shadow3.jpg

Links

theBookseller.com

The Book Standard

Buzz, Balls & Hype

Danuta Kean

Eco-Libris

Publishers Marketplace

Publishing Contrarian

Publishing For Profit

Publishing Insider

Publishing News

The Publishing Spot
Publishing Trends

Publishers Weekly

PubRants

Shelf Awareness

Weekly Publishing Moves

...more...

Archives

July 2008

June 2008

May 2008

April 2008

more...


Recent

Goading Dan Savage: PR Gold or Just Plain Trouble?

Can Science Fiction Go To Far?

Romance Writers Talk Trash

cats by Clipart.com, a service of Jupiterimages

Subscribe

Click here to receive the Daily Media News Feed by email.

Job Listings

Featured Listings

Assistant Editor- Higher Education
Oxford University Press
New York, NY

Director of Marketing and Trade Sales
Storey Publishing
North Adams, MA

Product Development Manager
Zagat Survey
New York, NY

Senior Business Analyst - Doubleday Publishing Group
Random House U.S.A
New York, NY

Become a partner


ADVERTISEMENT


mediabistro.com l Member Benefits l Jobs l Freelance Marketplace l Courses l Events l Forums l Content
mediabistro Blogs: Media News l TVNewser l GalleyCat l UnBeige l FishbowlNY l FishbowlLA l FishbowlDC l mbToolbox l PRNewser l AgencySpy l MobileContentToday
Site Map l Advertising/Sponsorships l Partners l About Us l Contact Us/Help

JupiterOnlineMedia

internet.comearthweb.comDevx.commediabistro.comGraphics.com

Search:

Jupitermedia Corporation has two divisions: Jupiterimages and JupiterOnlineMedia

Jupitermedia Corporate Info


Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, & Permissions, Privacy Policy.

Web Hosting | Newsletters | Tech Jobs | Shopping | E-mail Offers