Welcome back to another edition of FishbowlNY’s weekly Cover Battle. This time around Psychology Today takes on Sports Illustrated. PT went with a cover that daringly explores the taboo subject of Lone Ranger sex play. In this romping roleplay, yelling “Hi-yo Silver! Away!” takes on a whole new meaning and no one ever — ever — wants to be Tonto.

Sports Illustrated went with a photograph of Andrew Luck, the Colts’ rookie quarterback. Rumor has it that during this particular play call, Luck is audibling to a formation that sends the slot receiver in motion and makes Colts fans forget about some dude named Peyton Manning.

So readers, which cover is better? You can vote, comment, or do both.