FishbowlNY - Turning the Page For New York Media
Friday, Oct 03

Palination: A Morning After Round-Up

bidenpalinscottolsongetty.jpgWe took a stroll around the Internets this morning to see what Joe Klein, Peggy Noonan, Andrew Sullivan and other powers that be were saying about last night's debate. The general consensus? Palin exceeded her extremely low expectations. Also? SNL got lots of new material.

Peggy Noonan (WSJ): As far as Mrs. Palin was concerned, Gwen Ifill was not there, and Joe Biden was not there. Sarah and the camera were there. This was classic "talk over the heads of the media straight to the people," and it is a long time since I've seen it done so well, though so transparently. There were moments when she seemed to be doing an infomercial pitch for charm in politics. But it was an effective infomercial.

David Brooks (NYT): When nervous, Palin has a tendency to over-enunciate her words like a graduate of the George W. Bush School of Oratory, but Thursday night she spoke like a normal person. It took her about 15 seconds to define her persona — the straight-talking mom from regular America — and it was immediately clear that the night would be filled with tales of soccer moms, hockey moms, Joe Sixpacks, main-streeters, "you betchas" and "darn rights." Somewhere in heaven Norman Rockwell is smiling.



Tom Shales (WaPo): Sarah Palin looked as though she had prepared for her appearance at the vice presidential debate last night by studying Tina Fey's impressions of her on "Saturday Night Live." She twinkled and winked and piled on the perkiness, a "darn right" here and an "I'll betcha" there. At the same time, Palin seemed determined to banish thoughts of her as airheaded and inexperienced; she was really debating her own public image rather than Sen. Joe Biden. She subverted the whole purpose of the exercise by merely repeating the key points of her running mate, Sen. John McCain, and ignoring questions that called for more specific answers.

Politico: Millions of Americans were watching Thursday night's vice-presidential debate waiting for a demolition derby moment — another crash by GOP running mate Sarah Palin, another serving of raw material for the writers at "Saturday Night Live."

By that standard, she got out alive, though there were white-knuckle moments along the way: questions that were answered with painfully obvious talking points that betrayed scant knowledge of the issue at hand, and sometimes little relevance to the question that had been asked.

Andrew Sullivan: The campaign's trajectory remains unaltered. Palin's inability to answer real questions, her capacity to avoid follow-ups, her slightly manic quality, and her inability to relate to working class voters came across. Biden did not talk too much; he made no sexist gaffes; he didn't appear to be overweening; he seemed like a nice guy. I think she managed to avoid a tailspin; he reassured. It will stem the GOP collapse a little. But it won't change the race.

Mark Ambinder
: But the topline here is that, when it comes to worrying about Palin, the McCain campaign can now exhale ... (one GOPer e-mailed: "We live to fight another day.") ....and though, on paper, Palin said some weird things in weird ways (expanding the power of the vice presidency??) , she did nothing negatively indelibly memorable, and, at times, was positively impressive. She'll rev up partisan enthusiasm, and that's an accomplishment in and of itself. She was most effective when she argued against Barack Obama; mildly effective when she argued for John McCain's policies, and not terribly effective when it came to justifying why she was qualified to be vice presidentl of the United States.

Joe Klein (Time): She was animated and confident. She displayed an ability, for the first time since her convention speech, to repeat with a fair amount of credibility, the formulations that her handlers had given her. You knew she was well prepared when practically the first words out of her mouth were, "Go to a kids' soccer game..." She had that folksy thing down—although I did notice, watching the squiggly lines down at the bottom of the CNN screen, that when she tried to get cutesy with her folksiness, it didn't work.

She also was allowed to do fine by Joe Biden, who never really challenged her — his criticisms were always directed at John McCain — and never exposed the obvious shallowness of her knowledge on most topics. (He must have been sorely tempted to correct Palin when she called David McKiernan, the commanding general in Afghanistan, "McLellan," but Biden was hard-wired — I imagine his debate prep was a form of electric shock therapy — not to correct her, attack her, disrespect her.)

new on mediabistro.com

The Future of Social Media with Chris Anderson

The editor of Wired explains how to create a social network that works.
Watch the video

Email This Post

Fill out the following information and click on the Send button in order to send this post, Palination: A Morning After Round-Up, to a friend.
Friend's name
Friend's email address
Your name
Your email address
Note to your friend (optional, max 200 Characters)

Read more on FishbowlNY >

Turning the Page For New York Media
FishbowlNY in Your Inbox
Mobile Version
RSS Feed
Our Blog Network

BayNewser

WebNewser

TVNewser

PRNewser

MediaJobsDaily

GalleyCat

UnBeige

MobileContentToday

AgencySpy

FishbowlDC

FishbowlLA

FishbowlNY

FishbowlNY Staff
Editor:
Amanda Ernst

Contributing Editor:
Drew Grant

Columnist:
Diane Clehane

About FishbowlNY
Follow FishbowlNY
Email FishbowlNY

Anonymous Tips
Topics

About

About Us - Modules

Acquisitions

Advertising

Alternative Weeklies

AMC 2006

AMC 2007

AMC 2008

Awards

Beijing Olympics

Books

Bottom Feeding

Breaking News

Circulation

Daily Angle

Dissecting NPR

DNC '08

Election '08

Ellies '08

Fashion Week

Fishbowl Initiatives

FishbowlNY Poll

Inauguration '08

International

Keith Kelly Distilled

Legal Trouble

Lunch

Magazines

Markets & Media

Media Companies

Media Events

Media Lookbook

Media Minutiae

Media People

Mediabistro Circus

Memopad Distilled

Menu

Movies

New Media

News

Newspapers

NYT in 90 Seconds

Obituaries

Parties

Pop Culture

Radio

RNC '08

Scandals

Scholarly Pursuits

Strike Watch

SXSWi '08

The Crystal Ball

The Internet Presidency

The Revolving Door

The State of Journalism

Time 100

Trends

TV

Video

Archives

November 2009

October 2009

September 2009

August 2009

more...

Links

AdAge

Beet.tv

BusinessWeek | Fine on Media

Buzz Machine/Jarvis

The Colbert Report

The Corsair

Daily Show

Editor & Publisher

Ed2010

Folio:

Gawker

Gothamist

Guardian America | Media

HuffPo

IWantMedia

Marketwatch | Friedman

Mediaite

Mediapost

Media Wire Daily

NY Daily News

NY Mag | Daily Intelligencer

NY Observer | The Media Mob

NY Post | Keith Kelly

NYT | Media Decoder

The Onion

Paid Content

Poynter | Romenesko

Silicon Alley Insider

Slate | Jack Shafer

Wall Street Journal

WaPo | Media Notes

James Wolcott

WWD | Memo Pad

ADVERTISEMENT


mediabistro.com l Member Benefits l Jobs l Freelance Marketplace l Courses l Events l Forums l Content
mediabistro Blogs: Media News l TVNewser l GalleyCat l UnBeige l FishbowlNY l FishbowlLA l FishbowlDC l PRNewser l AgencySpy
MobileContentToday l WebNewser l BayNewser l MediaJobsDaily l mbToolbox
Site Map l Advertising/Sponsorships l Partners l About Us l Contact Us/Help

internet.commediabistro.comJusttechjobs.comGraphics.com

Search:

WebMediaBrands Corporate Info

Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, Permissions, Privacy Policy.
Advertise | Newsletters | Shopping | E-mail Offers