![]() |
|||||||||
The Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group is looking for a Marketing Manager. See all other great jobs at our Job Board.
Friday, Feb 25
Cast of Shadows, Part I of 2
That, more or less, is the first half of my response to a recent email I got about bloggers' (overly?) enthusiastic reaction to Kevin Guilfoile's upcoming book, Cast of Shadows. According to the email's author, The book is awful, it fails even as throw-away thriller, but Kevin will get a pass thanks to his connections to Radosh, Coudal, and the Morning News. This hypocritical clubbiness is turning the book blogs [into] the new establishment.Whether or not Cast of Shadows actually sucks -- and I'll get back to that in my next post -- the real target of the letter is bloggers' circle-jerk mentality. While I've always thought the MSM's response to blogs -- of all things! -- linking to each other, and treating each others' best posts with the same respect they'd show pieces in the NYT -- was absurd, I'm beginning to wonder if the letter's accusation of "hypocritical clubbiness," in relation to blogs' product-plugging, isn't so off-target. While blogs treat most books like they would celebrities -- at least, in the sense, that they feel free to openly critique them -- the more casual atmosphere of blogs (versus, say, newspapers' book reviews) has two obvious results: 1) bloggers feel comfortable encouraging readers to check out their friends' books, and 2) other bloggers have begun to count as friends -- i.e., people who can be publicly plugged, but not publicly critiqued. If blogs are moving -- as the suspiciously trend-hungry media occasionally suggests -- to the center of our literary culture, it's easy to wonder if they, even more so than traditional media, will fall prey to a "hypocritical clubbiness" -- one that's clear to everyone but them. Email This Post |
|
||||||||
|
Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, Permissions, Privacy Policy.
|