FishbowlNY
 
Receive mediabistro.com's Daily FishbowlNY Feed via email


Daily Media Newsfeed Click here to receive mediabistro.com's Daily Media Newsfeed via email.

Monday Oct 17, 2005

Judith Miller: Answers, barely

I'll tell you ONE thing about Scooter Libby.jpgFrom Saturday's New York Times:

And when the prosecutor in the case asked her to explain how "Valerie Flame" appeared in the same notebook she used in interviewing Mr. Libby, Ms. Miller said she "didn't think" she heard it from him. "I said I believed the information came from another source, whom I could not recall."
After an 85-day moral stand in prison and two weeks of silence from the NYT, Judith Miller, who made much of the fact that she did not even write a story on the subject, had two clear references to Valerie Plame in her notes, "Valerie Flame" and later "Valerie Wilson" -- and she claims she has no idea who she heard them from.*

The Times ran its long-promised story on Saturday, "The Miller Case: A Notebook, a Cause, a Jail Cell and a Deal," put together by the NYT's investigative team of Don Van Natta Jr., Adam Liptak, Clifford J. Levy and Janny Scott under the supervision of NYT deputy managing editor Jon Landman. The 5,800-word article sadly makes clear the stranglehold Judith Miller had over the Times, the lack of cooperation she offered, and the failure of Times leadership to control the situation (Jay Rosen, right on all counts.)

You can't help but feel bad for the New York Times: its leadership impugned, its staffers divided, its morale low, its reporters scooped regularly on its own story.

And meanwhile, Judith Miller, after incurring millions in legal fees, let her colleagues at the Times down in the most fundamental way: she refused to talk to them. "In two interviews," wrote the Times, "Ms. Miller generally would not discuss her interactions with editors, elaborate on the written account of her grand jury testimony or allow reporters to review her notes." A far cry from the story promised by Bill Keller, the story that they were "yearning" to write now that Miller had been released from her contempt charge.

But Keller had promised something he couldn't deliver; Judy was the one making the decisions, and she was making them alone:

But Mr. Sulzberger and the paper's executive editor, Bill Keller, knew few details about Ms. Miller's conversations with her confidential source other than his name. They did not review Ms. Miller's notes. Mr. Keller said he learned about the "Valerie Flame" notation only this month. Mr. Sulzberger was told about it by Times reporters on Thursday.

Interviews show that the paper's leaders, in taking what they considered to be a principled stand, ultimately left the major decisions in the case up to Ms. Miller, an intrepid reporter whom editors found hard to control.

They threw their money, editorial voice and critical support in the newsroom behind Judith Miller, and she threw the barest minimum back, even turning her copy in late so that the all-important investigative story missed the deadline for the paper's "bulldog" edition.

The picture that emerges is of a headstrong reporter who felt she could make her own rules (her description of herself as "Miss Run Amok" seems accurate), and an institution that failed to take control of its own story -- potentially a story with far-reaching implications into the highest levels of government. Ouch.

Some highlights:

  • Miller "would not discuss her sources" other than Scooter Libby, and claimed not to remember the source of the "Valerie Flame" name.

  • Keller actively took her off the WMD beat in July 2003, but she kept on "drifting on her own back into the national security realm." No one appeared to be directly in charge of her.

  • The Times' top management kept the identity of Miller's source to themselves; "[e]ven after reporters learned it from outside sources, the Times did not publish Mr. Libby's name, though other news organizations already had."

  • Miller told the Grand Jury that she interpreted Scooter Libby's letter mentioning how no reporters had discussed Plame with him "might be perceived as an effort by Mr. Libby to suggest that I, too, would say we had not discussed Ms. Plame's identity. Yet my notes suggested that we had discussed her job." Libby's lawyer apparently told Miller "don't go there" [Libby's complicity] about Libby during testimony.

  • Miller agreed to identify Libby as a "former Hill staffer" rather than a "senior administration official," which

  • Miller claimed that the "Aspens are turning" line was in reference to her running into Libby all decked like a cowboy and hadn't recognized him. I'm not buying it; it looks like Libby's a guy with lots to lose, and that purple prose smacks of some sort of deeper messge.

  • Miller is on a leave of absence from the Times and "hopes to return to the newsroom." There are many that hopes she does not. Oh yes, and guess what? Turns out she is writing a book. Huh. You don't say.


    The Miller Case: A Notebook, a Cause, a Jail Cell and a Deal [NYT]
    My Four Hours Testifying in the Federal Grand Jury Room [NYT]

    Related:
    Judith Miller and the New York Times: Comprehensive Coverage [PressThink]
    Arianna Huffington on Judy Miller [HuffPo]
    NY Times Publishes Devastating Article on Judith Miller Case, While Revealing Newsroom Controversy (plus links) [E&P]
    Judy Miller and the damage done [Salon]
    The Times Gives Us a Modified, Limited Hangout [CJR]
    Miller's Weak-end [FishbowlDC]
    The NYT Miller Revelations [Kausfiles](note his point on how Miller may actually have made it easier for the gov't to send reporters to jail!)

    Additional Fishbowl Coverage:

  • Judith Miller: Thoughts from the Armchair Critics
  • Judith Miller: Clues in "Hard News"
  • Switched at Birth? Judith Miller and Dawn Eden
  • Judith Miller: Postscript to the Postscript

    *As Farhad Manjoo points out in Salon, this does not necessarily exonerate Libby; it is still pretty clear that they discussed the fact that Wilson's wife worked for the CIA. Furthermore, Manjoo argues that Miller's testimony lays the foundation for Libby to be charged with either (or both) of breaking espionage law or obstruction of justice. Gulp. Not looking great for Libby!




  • new on mediabistro.com

    The Future of Social Media with Chris Anderson

    The editor of Wired explains how to create a social network that works.
    Watch the video

    Email This Post

    Fill out the following information and click on the Send button in order to send this post, Judith Miller: Answers, barely, to a friend.
    Friend's name
    Friend's email address
    Your name
    Your email address
    Note to your friend (optional, max 200 Characters)

    Read more on FishbowlNY >

    Interested in advertising on FishbowlNY?

    Our Blog Network

    TVNewser

    PRNewser

    GalleyCat

    UnBeige

    MobileContentToday

    MobileMarketingToday

    MobileDevicesToday

    MobileAppsToday

    AgencySpy

    FishbowlDC

    FishbowlLA

    FishbowlNY

    FishbowlNY: A blog about New York media

    Managing Editor:
    Rebecca L. Fox
    Co-Editors:
    Noah Davis
    Glynnis MacNicol
    Contributing Editor:
    Diane Clehane

      FBNY twitter feed loading...

    View twitter directly

    Follow FishbowlNY via Twitter

    Email:
    About
    Syndication

    Anonymous Tips


    Archives

    August 2008

    July 2008

    June 2008

    May 2008

    more...


    Recent

    Radar Ed. Glad People Pick Choke-ing Over Obama

    FishbowlNY Does the Cannonball Run to Minneapolis

    So Just How Successful Were NBC's Olympics?

    Categories

    About

    About Us - Modules

    Acquisitions

    Advertising

    Alternative Weeklies

    AMC 2006

    AMC 2007

    Awards

    Beijing Olympics

    Books

    Bottom Feeding

    Breaking News

    Circulation

    Daily Angle

    Dissecting NPR

    DNC '08

    Election '08

    Ellies '08

    Fashion Week

    Fishbowl Initiatives

    FishbowlNY Poll

    International

    Keith Kelly Distilled

    Lunch

    Magazines

    Markets & Media

    Media Companies

    Media Events

    Media Lookbook

    Media Minutiae

    Media People

    Memopad Distilled

    Movies

    New Media

    News

    Newspapers

    NYT in 90 Seconds

    Obituaries

    Parties

    Pop Culture

    Radio

    Scandals

    Scholarly Pursuits

    Strike Watch

    SXSWi '08

    The Crystal Ball

    The Revolving Door

    The State of Journalism

    Time 100

    TV

    Video

    Links

    AdAge

    Beet.tv

    BusinessWeek | Fine on Media

    Buzz Machine/Jarvis

    The Colbert Report

    The Corsair

    Daily Show

    Editor & Publisher

    Ed2010

    Folio:

    Gawker

    Gothamist

    Guardian America | Media

    HuffPo | Sklar/ETP

    IWantMedia

    Jossip

    Marketwatch | Friedman

    Mediapost

    Media Wire Daily

    NY Daily News | Gatecrasher

    NY Mag | Daily Intelligencer

    NY Observer | The Media Mob

    NY Post | Keith Kelly

    NY Sun

    NYT | Business

    The Onion

    Paid Content

    Portfolio | Bercovici

    Poynter | Romenesko

    Radar

    Radosh

    Rex Hammock

    Silicon Alley Insider

    Slate | Jack Shafer

    Wall Street Journal

    WaPo | Media Notes

    James Wolcott

    WWD

    Forum

    New York Issues 21 topics
    Seeking USA culture specialist (3) 8/27/2008
    Office/Writer's space available $500 (1) 8/25/2008
    Anybody live in Inwood? (7) 8/22/2008
    THE BLUECAT SCREENWRITING WORKSHOP COMES TO NYC! (1) 8/14/2008
    more... - post new topic

    Subscribe

    Click here to receive the Daily Media News Feed by email.

    Job Listings

    Featured Listings

    Web Editor/Reporter
    Technology Marketing Corporation
    Norwalk, CT

    Senior E-Marketing Manager
    MediMedia
    Stamford, CT

    Manager, Sales & Trade Communications
    UST, Inc.
    Stamford, CT

    Assistant Event Manager, Conferences
    Red 7 Media
    Norwalk, CT

    Upcoming


    Nonfiction Book Proposal Writing
    Avoid the slush pile with a polished proposal.
    September 3

    Memoir Writing
    Tell -- and sell -- the story of your life.
    September 4

    Grammar, Punctuation, and Meaning
    Master the basics and impress your editors.
    September 8


    Become a partner



    ADVERTISEMENT


    mediabistro.com l Member Benefits l Jobs l Freelance Marketplace l Courses l Events l Forums l Content
    mediabistro Blogs: Media News l TVNewser l GalleyCat l UnBeige l FishbowlNY l FishbowlLA l FishbowlDC l mbToolbox l PRNewser l AgencySpy l MobileAppsToday l MobileContentToday l MobileMarketingToday l MobileDevicesToday
    Site Map l Advertising/Sponsorships l Partners l About Us l Contact Us/Help

    JupiterOnlineMedia

    internet.comearthweb.comDevx.commediabistro.comGraphics.com

    Search:

    Jupitermedia Corporation has two divisions: Jupiterimages and JupiterOnlineMedia

    Jupitermedia Corporate Info


    Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, & Permissions, Privacy Policy.

    Web Hosting | Newsletters | Tech Jobs | Shopping | E-mail Offers