GalleyCat
 
Receive mediabistro.com's Daily GalleyCat Feed via email


Daily Media Newsfeed Click here to receive mediabistro.com's Daily Media Newsfeed via email.

Thursday, May 11

2nd Opinion: Did the NYTBR Fumble?

Beloved is the best American novel of the last twenty-five years? Say what? And don't hand me that "any other outcome would have been startling" nonsense, either. While we're at it, this survey doesn't prove that "the baby boom, long ascendant in popular culture and increasingly so in politics and business, has not produced a great novel;" it merely proves that out of the people whose opinions you solicited, only two of them gave props to The Things They Carried. And, too, one might consider the possibility of a brilliant boomer novel published before 1980; I'm willing to concede that no candidates are immediately springing to mind, but it's still pretty early in the morning here...

But let's consider how the NYTBR reached this decision. They say they reached out to 125 "writers, editors, and critics" for nominees, but if you look at the names on that list, there are only a few I'd call critics rather than writers who've written book reviews over the course of their careers—and even fewer editors. (If you read a bit further, you can see if my rough calculations make sense to you.) Furthermore, almost every one of those critics is old school media. Why not include voices from the blogosphere like Laila Lalami, Maud Newton, or Mark Sarvas? Heck, Lizzie Skurnick has even written for the Review already!

Returning to the writers, we have one who might be considered to traffic in genre fiction: Stephen King. Okay, two if you want to count Jonathan Lethem. And speaking of genre, if the Review is going to ask poetry columnist David Orr his opinion, why not check in with Marilyn Stasio and Dave Itzkoff? (Come to think of it, what's happened to Itzkoff's science fiction column, anyway? It's been over two months: Should we start worrying?) I'm not saying that I expected to see Ender's Game or L.A. Confidential or Masks of the Illuminati on the short-list, but at least they or some other non-mainstream novels might have gotten some votes if Sam Tanenhaus had cast his nets a little wider. And speaking of books that didn't get votes, I did appreciate the sly dig at "one best-selling author (whose fat novels seem to have been campaigning for inclusion in this issue long before the editors dreamed it up, even though not even he bothered to vote for any of them)," especially since I had been wondering how A Man in Full failed to get a vote from anybody. I had no idea so many people shared my belief that it completely falls apart in the final chapters!

I've frequently returned to one of Tanenhaus's earliest stated ambitions for the NYTBR—to deliver "news about the culture"—and this seems like another opportunity to revisit the question of whether he's fulfilled that mandate. I don't have an easy overall answer, because I believe he's been successful in some ways and unsuccessful in others. But here's the thing: If the Review really means to suggest that American literary culture peaked nearly two decades ago, shouldn't there be more to say about what that says about the contemporary culture or the people who are asked to arbitrate it than the tepid generalizations with which A.O. Scott concludes his contribution?


Here's how I tallied the critics and editors. Your results may vary, and if so, feel free to tell me.

  • Critics: Sven Birkerts, Harold Bloom, Richard Eder, David Gates, Henry Louis Gates, Jr., Frank Kermode, John Leonard, Ralph Lombreglia, Daphne Merkin, Geoffrey O'Brien, David Orr, Liesl Schillinger. Personally, I'm wavering on David Gates, who I'd consider a "writer," but he has a book reviewing job, so okay then...

  • Editors: Bill Buford, Morris Dickstein, Henry Finder, Deborah Treisman—three of whom are or have been associated with the New Yorker. If you want to boost the editor count somewhat, you could also add the following writers: Roger Angell (another New Yorker guy), Kurt Andersen (RIP Spy and Inside), Anne Fadiman (American Scholar, but she'll always be the author of one of the best non-fiction books of the last 25 years to me), and Philip Gourevitch (Paris Review, but I repeat what I said about Fadiman).

new on mediabistro.com

The Future of Social Media with Chris Anderson

The editor of Wired explains how to create a social network that works.
Watch the video

Email This Post

Fill out the following information and click on the Send button in order to send this post, 2nd Opinion: Did the <i>NYTBR</i> Fumble?, to a friend.
Friend's name
Friend's email address
Your name
Your email address
Note to your friend (optional, max 200 Characters)

Read more on GalleyCat >

The First Word on the Book Publishing Industry

Our Blog Network

BayNewser

WebNewser

TVNewser

PRNewser

MediaJobsDaily

FishbowlNY

FishbowlDC

FishbowlLA

MobileContentToday

AgencySpy

UnBeige

GalleyCat

GalleyCat Staff

Editor:

Jason Boog


Senior Editor:
Ron Hogan



Contact Us
Twitter


Anonymous Tips

Favorite Posts

heather-thomas-sidebar.jpg Our Chat With Heather Thomas
jack-oconnell-sidebar.jpg The (Long-Awaited) Return of Jack O'Connell
marya-hornbacher-sidebar.jpg Marya Hornbacher: "No Tortured Artists Here"
stean-sagmeister-sidebar.jpg Stefan Sagmeister: "Design for Non-Designers"
 Why Does Maureen Dowd Hate Popular Women?

Links

theBookseller.com

Buzz, Balls & Hype

Danuta Kean

E-Reads

Eco-Libris

Publishers Marketplace

Publishers Weekly

Publishing Contrarian

Publishing For Profit

Publishing Insider

Publishing News

The Publishing Spot

Publishing Trends

PubRants

Rick Frishman

Shelf Awareness

TeleRead

Weekly Publishing Moves

The Write Report

...more...

Archives

July 2009

June 2009

May 2009

April 2009

more...


Recent

Harper: Sarah Palin's Memoir Will Be "Huge"

Updating Cyrano for the YouTube Generation

A Moment of Appreciation for SIBA's Jewell

Subscribe

Click here to receive the Daily Media News Feed by email.

Job Listings

Featured Listings

Account Executive The Nest
The Knot, Inc.
Philadelphia, PA

Manager, Technical Services
Scholastic
Watertown, MA

Associate Publisher/Golf World
Conde Nast Publications
New York, NY

Marketing Manager
The Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group
Lanham, MD

ADVERTISEMENT


mediabistro.com l Member Benefits l Jobs l Freelance Marketplace l Courses l Events l Forums l Content
mediabistro Blogs: Media News l TVNewser l GalleyCat l UnBeige l FishbowlNY l FishbowlLA l FishbowlDC l PRNewser l AgencySpy
MobileContentToday l WebNewser l BayNewser l MediaJobsDaily l mbToolbox
Site Map l Advertising/Sponsorships l Partners l About Us l Contact Us/Help

internet.commediabistro.comJusttechjobs.comGraphics.com

Search:

WebMediaBrands Corporate Info

Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, Permissions, Privacy Policy.
Advertise | Newsletters | Shopping | E-mail Offers