AT&T Loses First Legal Battle, Makes Things Worse With Luke Wilson Ad

AT&T lost its first legal argument against Verizon Wireless, a blow that was only made worse when juxtaposed with their first rebuttal advertisement — an ad that more or less falls flat compared to Verizon's campaign.

Hoping to get Verizon's ads stricken from the airwaves, AT&T filed a restraining order — but an Atlanta judge turned down the request. It's just the first step in AT&T's legal battle, which hopes to prove that Verizon caused irreparable damage with ads claiming that AT&T's 3G network is lacking.

AT&T doesn't refute those claims, rather states that their competitor has confused consumers into thinking the 3G map shown represents the slower EDGE or GPR networks, which are used for basic services like calls and texts. Verizon has since modified the spots to clarify they're referring to 3G.

Maybe the most poignant move on Verizon's part came in their legal rebuttal, a 53-page document, stating AT&T is suing "because it doesn't want to face the truth about its network," reports CNET.

In what appears to be an attempt to counter Verizon's "There's a Map for That" campaign, AT&T has produced its own spot using actor Luke Wilson. A chubby-faced Wilson stands in front of a chalk board containing a checklist of features available to AT&T customers. He then asks which provider (AT&T or Verizon) has a certain feature, and puts an "X" next to the "better" company. Unsurprisingly, Verizon's only win is for "Name that starts with letter v."

"Hey, they got one," says Wilson. Here's what you get with AT&T:

1. "Nation's fastest 3G network"

2. "Talk and Surf at the same time"

3. "Access to over 100,000 apps"

Well Verizon's ads take care of number 1, since being fastest doesn't help when service is spotty. The second claim is easily defeated: think about the last time you spoke on the phone and surfed the Web — handy at times, but ultimately it's hard to pay attention to both at once. Also, the iPhone can't run multiple applications at once, a feature users seem to find more appealing. And who has the time to look through 100,000 apps?

That this is all AT&T could muster indicates the provider was not ready for such an attack, despite the fact that a major qualm among iPhone customers is the provider's 3G network (and has been for years). They've had more than enough time to both beef up their network, an effort that has likely been hampered by the high costs associated with the iPhone. For example, AT&T pays Apple not only for exclusive rights to the device but also every time a new customer buys one. Meanwhile Verizon has strengthened its 3G network while awaiting a competitive smart phone. And now they have three: HTC's Droid Eris, HTC's Imagio and Motorola's Droid.

More: "AT&T to Verizon: 'There's a Lawsuit for That'"


New from mediabistro.com

20 Tips in 20 Minutes
mediabistro.com's PR Speaking Series: Online & In Person

The phone rings. It's CNBC. They want your CEO in the studio and on air. In three hours. Oh, and your CEO has never done a broadcast interview. What do you do? Find out at our new monthly breakfast speaking series for PR and marketing professionals, "20 Tips in 20 Minutes." Our next topic is "Media Training: How to Prep Your Company, Client, and Yourself for Interviews," with Garrett Glaser, former CNBC and MSNBC.com reporter and founder of Glaser Media LLC at 9am on Thursday, February 18. Join us for breakfast or watch the live webcast from your desk. Click here to sign up and view the full schedule of topics.

Email This Post

Fill out the following information and click on the Send button in order to send this post, AT&T Loses First Legal Battle, Makes Things Worse With Luke Wilson Ad, to a friend.
Friend's name
Friend's email address
Your name
Your email address
Note to your friend (optional, max 200 Characters)

Read more on AgencySpy >

Inside Your Agency. Deep Inside

AgencySpy in Your Inbox
Our Blog Network

BayNewser

WebNewser

TVNewser

PRNewser

FishbowlNY

FishbowlDC

FishbowlLA

MediaJobsDaily

GalleyCat

eBookNewser

UnBeige

MobileContentToday

AgencySpy

AgencySpy Editors
Matt Van Hoven
AIM/Twitter: agencyspy

Kiran Aditham
AIM/Twitter: PvnkFreud

Tipline:
212.547.7935

Email AgencySpy

Follow AgencySpy
Topics

2008 Prez Election

About

About Us - Modules

Aegis

Agencies

Agency.com

AKQA

Ambient

Anomaly

Arnell

Arnold Worldwide

Avenue A/Razorfish

Awards

Bartle Bogle Hegarty

BBDO

Berlin Cameron United

Blind Item

Booked

Boutique Call

Brands

Broadcast

Campaigns

Campbell Ewald

Carat

Celebrity

Comment of the Day

Conferences

Craigslist is Your Hero

Cramer-Krasselt

Crispin Porter & Bogusky

DDB

Deep Focus

Dentsu

Designing (Wo)Men

Deutsch

Digitas

Doner

DraftFCB

Droga5

Element79

Enfatico

EuroRSCG

Fallon

Gaming

GlobalHue

Go Twitter, Go

Goodby

Grey Worldwide

GroupM

GSD&M

Ha!

Hal Riney

Hot Ad (Wo)Man Of The Day

I Have Twatted

Interpublic

J. Walter Thompson

Kirshenbaum Bond

Leo Burnett

MadMen, The Musical

Martin Williams

McCann

Mcgarrybowen

MDC Partners

Media Beat

Media Buying

Mediabistro

MediaVest

MindShare

Mobile

Mother

Moving Pictcha

Mullen

Music!

Naked

News

No Wukkas - The Job Hunt

Ogilvy

OMD

Omnicom

Online

Op-Eds

Outdoor

Party Party!

People

PHD

Planning/Consumer Insights

Poke

Print

Publicis

R/GA

Raw and Uncut

Razorfish

Reading List

Saatchi & Saatchi

Social Media

Spot Runner

StrawberryFrog

Stupid Intern

Sustainability

Target

TBWA/Chiat Day

Television

The Martin Agency

The Menu

The Richards Group

The Spies

The Super Bowl

Tribal DDB

We Hear...

Week in Advertising

What The...?

Wieden & Kennedy

WPP

Young & Rubicam

Links

mb News Feed
5 Blogs Before Lunch
AdAge
AdForum
AdFreak
AdLand
Adomatica
AdsOfTheWorld
AdScam
Adverganza
Advergirl
Adweek
Denver Egotist
Illegal Advertising
Mediaweek
MyOpenKimono
The Toad Stool
Please Feed the Animals
TribbleAgency

Archives

February 2010

January 2010

December 2009

November 2009

more...


Job Listings

Featured Listings

Media Planner
Marketing Drive, LLC
Boston, MA

Business Development Director, Custom Research
Independent Marketing Research Company
Los Angeles, CA

Account Director
Marketing Drive, LLC
Boston, MA

Assistant Account Executive
Marketing Drive, LLC
Boston, MA


mediabistro.com l Member Benefits l Jobs l Freelance Marketplace l Courses l Events l Forums l Content
mediabistro Blogs: Media News l TVNewser l GalleyCat l UnBeige l FishbowlNY l FishbowlLA l FishbowlDC l PRNewser l AgencySpy
MobileContentToday l WebNewser l BayNewser l eBookNewser l MediaJobsDaily l mbToolbox
Site Map l Advertising/Sponsorships l Partners l About Us l Contact Us/Help

WebMediaBrands
mediabistro learnnetwork freelanceconnect SemanticWeb
Jobs | Events | News
Copyright 2010 WebMediaBrands Inc. All rights reserved.
Advertise | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy