We’ve written a good bit about the use and abuse of fake “user reviews” recently, and we couldn’t help but share this bizarre story of a “crowdsourced” effort to sink a certain Amazon bestseller—all organized and executed by people who hadn’t actually read the book in question.

The reason for this anti-PR stunt is a little unusual. The book, titled “Tinderbox: How the West Sparked the AIDS Epidemic and How the World Can Finally Overcome It“, is by (almost) all accounts a well-researched tome that traces the history of the AIDS epidemic, the effect of Western colonialism on its gradual spread and the potential for the West to curtail it via international policy. The book also happens to contain a section on the importance of male circumcision as a preventive measure used to reduce HIV rates in certain Western African countries. (Multiple studies have shown the practice to lower HIV infection rates by as much as 70%.)

Here’s the catch: a small and extremely devoted group of activists really hate circumcision for some reason. At their most extreme, they compare the practice to female genital mutilation (a custom unfortunately common in some societies that is in no way similar to male circumcision), arguing that it violates the rights of newborns and that all studies extolling its health benefits are junk science.

They get into some conspiracy theories and vaguely anti-Semitic themes as well, but we won’t elaborate on those here. Let’s just say their efforts remind us of Scientology’s ongoing war against psychiatry or the activists who continue to claim that childhood vaccines cause autism.

So a group of these anti-circumcision activists organized a smear campaign on the book’s Amazon page:

Read more