TVNewser AgencySpy TVSpy LostRemote FishbowlNY FishbowlDC SocialTimes AllFacebook 10,000 Words GalleyCat UnBeige MediaJobsDaily

Kellogg Agrees: ‘All-Natural’ Means Absolutely Nothing


Earlier this week, The New York Times columnist/nutritionist/penultimate “foodie” Mark Bittman wrote an op-ed about our consumer culture’s over-emphasis on the word “organic.”

His point? Eating better and living healthier lives has very little to do with whether the products one buys are technically organic–even though there’s a clear and important distinction between agricultural practices that qualify and those that don’t. Non-organic lettuce, for example, is far healthier than organic crackers–and the fact that Ben & Jerry’s products hew to certain production standards does not in any way mean that they’re healthy.

When it comes to marketing practices, of course, it’s a different story–and Kellogg is only the latest company to agree (under court order) that the phrase “all-natural” as it exists in the market today is completely meaningless.

Remember Naked Juice?

Companies can use labels to imply whatever the hell they want.

While “all-natural” implies that a product has certain vague health properties, it really has no specific connotation–and we can blame the FDA’s inaction for this (at least in part). So when a Kellogg spokesperson tells the Times:

“We stand behind our advertising and labeling practices…and will continue to ensure our foods meet our high quality and nutrition standards while delivering the great taste people expect.”

…he/she is not technically lying.

The issue is that Kashi cereal, long seen as the healthiest thing around primarily because it tastes like toasted cardboard, claimed to be “all-natural” while containing:

“…ingredients like pyridoxine hydrochloride, calcium pantothenate and soy oil processed using hexane, a component of gasoline.”

Again, this isn’t a straight-up lie because such elements do occur in nature–but they’re processed using components that you will never find on a pristine forest floor.

While it’s ridiculous for consumers to believe that a bunch of bran flakes will prevent cancer or improve their “heart health” or generally give them a certain kind of “glow”, it’s also ridiculous for brands to base perceptions of their products on such meaningless claims.

The big problem: until the FDA gets its sh*t together and defines common phrases like these, companies will continue using them–while getting sued and suffering terrible publicity for doing so.

Mediabistro Course

Storytelling for Media Professionals

Storytelling for Media ProfessionalsLearn how to use stories to inspire, connect, and persuade your clients! In this workshop starting September 3, you'll learn how to uncover stories in everyday life, incorporate stories into your media work, use storytelling techniques with clients, all to improve your pitch and presentation skills. Register now!