Reviewing Monocle Like A Rock Record

Tyler Brűlé's latest offering is cold, dark, expensive — the anti-Wallpaper*

March 13, 2007
monocle_rock.jpgFor a magazine that carries a $10 cover price, Monocle, the much-anticipated offering from Wallpaper* founder Tyler Brűlé, garnered a relatively disproportionate amount of press up leading up to its launch last month. When we finally got ahold of a copy, its juxtaposition with Brűlé's old Wallpaper* digs was striking. Out: Big, colorful, bounding glossy pages; oversized images; sleek, mod layouts awash in bold, eye-searing color. In: Cold, primary colors; small trim size; text-heavy layouts; kitschy photography that's drab and decidedly not sleek. It's as if Brűlé and a band of highbrow magazine executives set out to create the world's coolest history textbook.

If that was the goal, they didn't fail, but they've not yet succeeded, either.

The Ads:
There are plenty, though, like Monocle's pages, they are not glossy. A few could-be Wallpaper* holdovers -- Cartier, Versace, modern furniture houses and designer watchmakers -- but the majority are upscale sartorial buys, mostly for men's threads. An errant ad for the International Herald Tribune seems out-of-place until you realize that IHT struck an exclusive content distribution deal with Brűlé, announced shortly before Monocle's launch.
The Features:
Wallpaper*'s trademark was its design. Big Monocle's seems to be its reporting. Brűlé dispatched some 60 "editors, writers, researchers, translators, photographers and fixers" across 50 locations and six continents for its premiere issue. As the magazine states in its "World view" opener, "sharp and original reportage is core to Monocle's editorial mission, both in print and online." The coverage is vast -- business, culture, design rub up against NBC's Ann Curry (yes, her) -- and literally globe-spanning (a profile of Kitakoga, Europe's highest city, alongside Ensenada, "the about to boom town" will make you feel fleetingly cool).

Globe-trotting content does have a downside: Monocle's "Sunday Best," its take on products for the "perfect Sunday morning" ("a cycle through Lisbon, our ideal media menu and a brunch prepared by our Aussie friends") is as pretentious as it gets. Sample passage: "Then it's time to run by supercool Sneaker Delight and pluck a pair of Pumas off the trainer tree erected by artist Joao Pedro Vale before heading to the in-house hairdresser for a trim." Monocle's media coverage, though, shows great promise: a diary of an unanonymous producer at Sundance refreshingly ripping Graydon Carter's Chicago 10 ("It's repetitive, noisy and frustrating") a first look at Wall Street Journal-backed India financial daily, Mint, and a profile of Massoud Sanjer, Kabul's Howard Stern.

The Design:
That's not to say that Monocle is not concerned with design. Far from it. It's just such a stark contrast from Wallpaper*'s bright, bold waves that one tends to forget the subtleness of it all. Brűlé's trademarks remain: crisp, clean layout is on display throughout its 239 pages. But it's more textbook than textbook design -- not necessarily a bad thing.
The Extras:
Not many to speak of. In fact, none at all, save for the various global maps -- seemingly inspired by war rooms -- pinpointing the point of dispatch.
Overall:
Monocle purports to be a "Briefing on Global Affairs, Business Culture & Design." It is anything but brief. It's better served as a textbook -- both in design and context -- for the nouveau-riche. But it marks Tyler Brűlé's passage into his post-Wallpaper* print years. He wants to be globally relevant. That Monocle doesn't smack of desperation is admirable. But there's no way anyone who doesn't have patience for a high-end literary journal's gonna read it.

Monocle | Issue 1, Vol. 1 | March 2007 | 3.75 (out of 5)

[Dylan Stableford is mediabistro.com's managing editor, media news and editor of FishbowlNY. He can be reached at dylan AT mediabistro DOT com.]

> Have a comment? Send a letter to the editor.
> Read more in our archives